24 Apr 2013
Today, 24 April, saw history made. The UK parliament has
passed a new Defamation Bill, which will now go on to Royal Assent. A major
victory against censorship in Britain and beyond has been won, with England’s
notorious libel laws changed in favour of free speech.
The creation of this new law has not been an easy process.
The Libel Reform Campaign launched
on 9 December 2009, bringing together Index on Censorship, English PEN and Sense About Science. We had all
identified a simple problem: English libel laws were silencing legitimate
criticism and debate — not just in the UK but internationally. London’s High
Court was seen as the place to come to silence opponents and critics, whether
you were a South African snake-oil salesman or a Saudi sheikh.
Each organisation had already been alarmed by the use of
libel laws in England and Wales to silence free speech.
The movement galvanised around the case of Simon Singh vs
the British Chiropractic Association. This case, involving the popular science
writer’s critique of what he now famously described as the “bogus” claims of
alternative medicine, brought the UK’s energetic sceptic community into the
fold. Over 100 civil society groups signed up. Novelists, journalists, lawyers
and comics — especially comics — also joined. At the same time, English PEN and
Index on Censorship had been working on a year-long study on the effects of
English libel law on chilling free speech at home and across the globe. The
Free Speech For Sale report kicked off a national debate on the impact of these
archaic laws.
In March 2010, some of the biggest names in comedy,
including Shappi Khorsandi, Tim Minchin andDara Ó Briain gave their time to
perform at the Big Libel Gig fundraiser in London.
An awful lot has happened since that benefit gig. Sheikh
Khalid Bin Mahfouz, a serial libel tourist, has died. Mr Justice Eady, the High
Court judge at the centre of some of the most contentious libel cases of recent
times, has retired. Barack Obama signed
the SPEECH Act, a US law specifically designed to protect Americans from
London libel rulings. And the Chiropractics lost their case against Singh.
But what did not change was the remarkable loyal support of
the thousands of libel reform supporters at home and abroad.
In advance of the 2010 UK election, tens of thousands of
people wrote to their MPs telling them to support reform of the libel laws. As
a result, all three main parties in the UK pledged to change the law.
When the Conservative-Liberal Democrat coalition government
was formed by David Cameron and Nick Clegg after that election, a new
defamation bill was one of the few issues both parties agreed on.
It would have been easy then for the 60,000 libel reform
supporters to feel that their job had been done, and that now it could be left
to the politicians.
But this never happened. Every time there was even a
slightest threat to the process of reform, supporters mobilised, often without
prompting.
The Libel Reform campaign can be seen, perhaps, as the first
successful political campaign of the social media age. Bloggers and tweeters
got involved and stayed involved. The #LibelReformhashtag
was never dormant.
It was also a good example of parliamentary policy making.
Though at times progress seemed slow, the bill went through rounds of scrutiny
in an open and transparent manner, with politicians (for the most part!)
working together for the common good.
The new law protects free speech. There is a hurdle to stop
vexatious cases. We now have a bar on libel tourism so non-EU claimants will
now need to prove that harm has been done here. For the first time there will
be a statutory public interest defence that will ask defendants to prove they
have acted “reasonably” (a better test than the more burdensome Reynold’s test
of responsible publication). There is also a hurdle to stop corporations from
suing unless they can prove financial harm.
The fight for free speech continues, but today Index would
like to thank our partners and supporters for what has been an incredible
three-and-a-half-year adventure.
Padraig Reidy is Senior Writer at Index on Censorship. @mePadraigReidy YOU MAY ALSO LIKE -
No comments:
Post a Comment